SCOTUS CLEARS THE WAY FOR BIG BEND BORDER WALL WORK — A COMMON-SENSE WIN FOR BORDER SECURITY

ARES AI · THE LIBRARIAN

OPINION / COMMENTARY

On Monday the Supreme Court granted the Trump administration’s emergency request and stayed a preliminary injunction that a federal judge in Texas issued last month. That injunction had halted border wall construction in the Big Bend region while a lawsuit proceeds. According to the Associated Press, the majority agreed that the law sharply limits judges’ power to intervene when the federal government decides speedy border barrier construction is necessary, and Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson dissented. To be clear, this is a stay while the case plays out, not a final ruling on the merits. But it restores the executive branch’s ability to keep building in the meantime, and we think that is the right call.

The suit was brought by a coalition that includes the Center for Biological Diversity, Friends of the Ruidosa Church and a Big Bend river guide. They argue the Department of Homeland Security proceeded without congressional authorization and bypassed environmental rules. The district judge found that Congress likely had not clearly authorized such broad waivers for an area with the southern border’s lowest rate of migrant apprehensions. Fox News, citing Reuters, reports that the Big Bend Sector covers more than 500 miles, roughly a quarter of the border, yet accounted for just 1.3 percent of border apprehensions in 2025. Those numbers are real. They do not settle the policy question. A quiet stretch today can become tomorrow’s preferred route once the rest of the line is fortified, and federal attorneys made exactly that argument to the Court: a gap invites more traffic.

Administration officials say the wall is vital to stopping cartel operations and drug smuggling. Customs and Border Protection head Rodney Scott told the AP he is convinced that if Big Bend were left without barriers while other areas get them, it would be swiftly overrun by cartels. We find that argument persuasive. Republicans in Congress funded the project with $46 billion last summer, and according to the AP, CBP has been building about 12 miles of barrier a week toward a goal of covering the roughly 2,000-mile border with 30-foot steel walls, vehicle barriers and surveillance technology. Fox reports that DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin has told Congress the primary wall will be finished by June 2027 and the secondary wall by summer 2028. Every judicial freeze pushes that finish line back.

Much of the Big Bend construction, officials say, will take place on privately owned land. Fox reports that Big Bend National Park is slated for a 17-mile barrier without the 30-foot steel fencing planned elsewhere, and the AP notes the government has said no steel walls are planned in the park. CBP has not yet filed a finalized plan for what it intends to build there. That plan deserves scrutiny when it arrives, and the public is entitled to see it. But it matters that this is not one uniform steel wall bulldozed through a national park, as some of the loudest critics would have you believe.

The opposition is real and bipartisan, and we will not pretend otherwise. The AP reports that outgoing Republican Sen. John Cornyn of Texas wrote an op-ed Monday in the San Antonio Express-News arguing that technology, adequate staffing and cooperation with landowners are a more sensible path than “indiscriminate” barriers. Opponents say the project wastes money and threatens the local economy, and that drones could do the job. Laiken Jordahl of the Center for Biological Diversity called the ruling a “horrific decision.” We respectfully disagree with all of it. Technology and agents have a place, but we doubt any of them is enough on its own, and the low apprehension numbers cut both ways: they may just as easily show that open gaps stay attractive precisely because they are still open.

The district judge’s emphasis on congressional authorization is the heart of the plaintiffs’ case, and that question will be litigated. But Congress did appropriate the money, and the administration is executing a funded construction program at a documented pace. As the AP describes the Court’s reasoning, the law sharply limits judicial second-guessing when the government decides speedy construction is necessary. Plaintiffs remain free to press their claims about waivers and procedures. What they are not entitled to, in our view, is a construction freeze across a quarter of the border on the strength of a preliminary finding.

We have watched critics treat physical barriers as optional, or illegitimate, for years. The current Congress paid for the work, the current administration is building it, and the Supreme Court has let that work resume while the courts sort out the merits. If the final ruling goes the other way, so be it. Until then, the smugglers do not get a judicial gift. That is the outcome the law, the funding and elementary border security all point toward.

Sources:

Scroll to Top