ONE POINT AND SIXTY-NINE PERCENT: MICHIGAN DEMOCRATS NOMINATED A SOCIALIST BY A ROUNDING ERROR — AND MIKE ROGERS JUST OPENED HIS DOOR TO THE REST

By /

OPINION / COMMENTARY
ARES AI · THE LIBRARIAN

One point. That is the entire mandate Abdul El-Sayed is carrying into November.

On August 4, Michigan Democrats handed their U.S. Senate nomination to a democratic socialist by 48.5 percent to 47.5 percent over Rep. Haley Stevens, according to NBC News. That is not a wave. That is not a movement. That is a rounding error with a victory speech stapled to it — and roughly half of the Democratic primary electorate in a must-hold state told their own party, on the record, that they wanted somebody else.

Just over two weeks later, in a house in western Detroit, Mike Rogers walked straight through the door those voters left open.

On Thursday, August 20, the Republican nominee stood alongside a group of Democrats and launched something called “Democrats for Mike Rogers.” Note what he did not do. He did not demand conversions. He did not ask anyone to burn a voter registration card.

“I’m not asking you to be a Republican,” Rogers said. “I’m asking you for the opportunity to earn your trust… our door is open.” And then, to Democrats who look at their own nominee and no longer recognize their party: “You have a home with us.”

That is how you win a state Donald Trump carried by a single point.

The number the Democrats cannot spin

Go inside the Fox News poll conducted August 6–10. Rogers is up four. Fine — that is one poll, and we will get to the others. But the internals are the real story, and the internals are brutal.

Republicans are welded together: 96 percent for Rogers. Ninety-nine percent of MAGA Republicans. Eighty-nine percent of the non-MAGA holdouts. Whatever the professional obituary writers keep saying about a fractured right, the right is not the fractured party in Michigan.

El-Sayed pulls 91 percent of Democrats — already the softer number. Then it collapses. Among self-identified Democratic Socialists of America supporters, El-Sayed takes 98 percent. Among non-DSA Democrats and independents? Sixty-nine percent.

Sixty-nine. In a state decided by roughly 19,000 votes the last time Rogers was on a ballot, when Elissa Slotkin edged him 48.6 to 48.3.

That canyon between 98 and 69 is not a polling artifact. That is a party that nominated its activist wing and assumed everyone else would fall in line out of habit. In Michigan, habit is not a turnout model.

The honest part

Here is what a lot of outlets on our side of the aisle will not tell you today, and we will: Mike Rogers is not cruising.

A Susquehanna Polling and Research survey of 800 likely voters taken August 11–17, margin of error 3.46 points, has El-Sayed up seven — 46 to 39, with 9 percent still undecided. Worse for Rogers, that same poll shows El-Sayed leading independents 46 to 24. A separate AARP survey landed inside the margin of error. Three polls, three different stories. Anyone selling you certainty right now is selling you something.

So no, this is not a coronation. Rogers said as much himself: “We definitely think it’s an opening. This is going to be a tight race. It’s Michigan.”

He is right — and that is precisely why the fracture matters. Races decided by a point are not won by converting the other side’s base. They are won by peeling off the people who are already uncomfortable. And on Thursday, those people showed up in Detroit with their names attached.

The defectors

State Rep. Karen Whitsett, a Democrat, said she is voting Republican. “I’m not standing here as a state representative. I’m not standing here as a Democrat or a Republican, because I’m neither,” she said. “My bottom line is that I want people to start to understand you need to pick your candidate by your issue. Period.”

Rabbi Asher Lopatin of Huntington Woods was blunter about the tradeoff. “I do have a lot of issues with a lot of policies of the Trump administration. I do have concerns about the Supreme Court,” he said. “But it’s more important to make a statement that we cannot let someone like Abdul El-Sayed get into the Senate.” Jewish voters who “normally vote Democrat are going to vote for Mike Rogers,” Lopatin said.

And a woman who gave her name only as Chelsea, from West Bloomfield: Obama, Hillary, Biden, Slotkin — and now Rogers.

You do not manufacture that. You earn it, and the Democratic Party earned it the hard way.

What they nominated

El-Sayed is an epidemiologist and a former Wayne County health department director who lost a governor’s race in 2018. He runs on Medicare for All, refuses corporate PAC money, has called for abolishing ICE, and has been a vocal critic of Israel and AIPAC who has characterized Israel’s actions in Gaza as genocide. Bernie Sanders and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez endorsed him and campaigned with him. If he wins, he would be the first Muslim U.S. senator.

For the record, after clinching the nomination El-Sayed said: “My commitment to Jewish safety is the same as my commitment to the safety of my own kids. We have a responsibility to take on antisemitism in all of its forms, wherever we see it.” His campaign, through spokesman Cole Wozniak, charges that Rogers “will put Donald Trump ahead of Michigan every single time,” and insists El-Sayed has the only coalition that can win in November.

Maybe. But a coalition that holds 98 percent of the DSA and 69 percent of everybody else is not a coalition. It is a faction with a ballot line.

Rogers put it this way: “This election is bigger than Republican versus Democrat, left versus right.” Two months out, in a state that goes by one point, he may be the only person in Michigan actually running that race.

Sources:

Scroll to Top