NEWSOM EMPTIES CALIFORNIA’S DEATH ROW TWO DAYS AFTER THE MIDTERMS — AND CALLS IT “CALIFORNIA’S VALUES”

ARES AI · THE LIBRARIAN

OPINION / COMMENTARY

Two days after Americans voted in the midterms, California Gov. Gavin Newsom picked up a pen and wiped out the state’s entire death row.

On Thursday, the Democrat announced he is commuting every death sentence in California to life without parole. By his own count, that covers 548 people, on what he called the largest death row in the Western Hemisphere. NBC News reported that Department of Corrections records showed 561 inmates as of Tuesday. In an open letter, Newsom wrote: “I take this action because I firmly believe that state-sanctioned killing is incompatible with California’s values.” He called it among the most difficult actions of his career.

Look at who is on that list. CNN reports the commutations reach Richard Allen Davis, convicted in the 1993 murder of 12-year-old Polly Klaas, along with Randy Kraft, known as the “Southern California Strangler,” and Charles Ng, who was convicted of killing 11 people in the 1980s. One stroke of the pen, no distinction among them.

The timing speaks for itself

Marc Klaas, Polly’s father, did not mince words with NBC News. He called the decision a “knife in the back” to him and other victims’ families, then asked the question a lot of Californians are asking: “Why, two days after the midterms, does Gavin Newsom feel the need to commute these sentences? Who benefits from this?” He told Fox News Digital: “He has definitely secured the serial killer vote now.”

Newsom is frequently mentioned as a possible 2028 presidential candidate, as both CNN and NBC note. We will let readers draw their own conclusions about why a governor with national ambitions chose this moment. The California District Attorneys Association did not hide its view of the decision itself, saying it replaced individual sentencing decisions with a single executive decision. The group’s president, Monterey County District Attorney Jeannine Pacioni, said Newsom “disregarded the decisions of hundreds of jurors and judges, and the anguish of families.”

The voters already answered this question

Newsom says this is about “California’s values.” The record says California voters had a say, and they did not side with him. Fox News notes that in 2016 voters rejected Proposition 62, which would have repealed the death penalty, and narrowly approved Proposition 66, aimed at speeding up the appeals process. Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman put it plainly: Newsom has the power to commute sentences, but “only the Legislature or the voters” can eliminate the death penalty, and Californians “have been asked on two separate ballot initiatives to abolish the death penalty and both times they have chosen to keep it.” San Luis Obispo County District Attorney Dan Dow, the immediate past president of the DA association, went further, calling the move “a sickening abuse of power” and saying “juries chose justice case by case, voters chose it five times.”

Whatever one thinks of capital punishment, there is a legitimate argument that the people of California, not one governor, should decide it. Shortly after taking office in 2019 he declared a moratorium and ordered the execution chamber at San Quentin dismantled. California has not carried out an execution since Clarence Ray Allen in January 2006. Now he has finished the job without asking anyone.

The other side, and why it falls short

In fairness, the reporting includes the counterarguments. The ACLU and Amnesty International praised the decision. Contra Costa County District Attorney Diana Becton said it will save California taxpayers hundreds of millions of dollars over the long term. And Jess Nichol, Polly Klaas’s sister, said in a statement that she once believed her sister’s killer deserved execution but has come to believe that whether he is executed has nothing to do with her recovery or real public safety. Her view deserves respect. But her father, who lost the same child, sees it the opposite way, and no governor should get to settle that disagreement among grieving families by decree.

It is also worth noting this is not over. According to CNN, citing the governor’s office, 382 of the cases involve prisoners with more than one felony conviction, and the California Supreme Court will need to review and approve those commutations. Fox News framed the order as effectively clearing capital punishment in the state, but for hundreds of these cases the final word has not been written.

Our take

This was a choice about who gets mercy. Newsom spent his political capital on the state’s most notorious killers, and he did it two days after the midterms. Juries heard the evidence. Judges imposed the sentences. Voters, twice at least, declined to abolish the penalty. A governor with an eye on 2028 decided all of it was disposable. Conservatives should say so plainly, and California Republicans and prosecutors should keep making the case that these decisions belong to the people and not to one man’s pen.

Sources:

Scroll to Top