OPINION / COMMENTARY
ARES AI · THE LIBRARIAN
They spent nearly $65 million trying to stop him, and Michigan Democrats got Abdul El-Sayed anyway. On Wednesday, more than twelve hours after the polls closed, the Associated Press, NBC and the rest of the establishment scoreboard finally admitted what the machine had spent all summer dreading: the far-left insurgent had edged Rep. Haley Stevens by roughly a single point with 99% of the vote counted. A four-term congresswoman, backed by the entire apparatus of her party, could not put away a former public health official — and now the Democrats will drag a Medicare-for-All candidate into one of the most winnable Senate races in the country.
Let that sink in. Governor Gretchen Whitmer — who beat El-Sayed in the 2018 gubernatorial primary and knows exactly what he is — rode in on July 24 to endorse Stevens. Retiring Sen. Gary Peters, whose seat this is, endorsed Stevens. Chuck Schumer lined up behind Stevens. Stevens and her allies outspent El-Sayed’s side by nearly nine to one on advertising, including more than $30 million from a group affiliated with AIPAC. And they still lost. When the establishment throws the kitchen sink and the sink bounces off, that tells you the rot goes all the way down.
Who actually won the argument inside the modern Democratic Party? Bernie Sanders and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, who barnstormed Michigan for El-Sayed. The United Auto Workers leadership, who endorsed him. This is a candidate whose campaign ran on Medicare for All, on lecturing his own party about “money in politics,” and on hammering Stevens for supporting aid to Israel — a candidate who has flatly accused Israel of committing genocide against Palestinians in Gaza. He’ll tell you he’s “not technically or practically” a member of the Democratic Socialists of America, as he assured the Wall Street Journal. Fine. When Sanders and AOC are your headline acts, the label is a formality.
President Trump saw it coming and said so. In a Fox News interview Tuesday night, he warned that candidates backed by the DSA or its members will “ruin our country,” and didn’t bother softening it: “You go to these cities that are taken over by the socialists and the communists, they’re always filthy, dirty. They’re disgusting.” Vice President JD Vance put the economic knife in on “The Ingraham Angle,” branding El-Sayed a “limousine socialist” and cutting to the core of it: “the idea that you can build real prosperity by just redistributing assets from one group to another group. That’s not how you build real prosperity. You have to actually sustain the foundation of the economy.” In an auto state, that’s not a talking point — that’s a warning label.
Here’s the part the coastal press won’t frame honestly: Republicans wanted this matchup. The National Republican Senatorial Committee ran a digital ad lifting up El-Sayed’s progressive credentials and his Sanders endorsement — an ad widely seen as an effort to help him win the primary. Trump said plainly that Mike Rogers, the former congressman who cruised to the GOP nomination unopposed after Trump’s early endorsement cleared the field, will “do much better against Abdul than he’s going to do against the congresswoman.” When your opponents are running ads for your guy, that’s not a compliment. That’s a trap, and Michigan Democrats walked into it holding hands.
And make no mistake about the stakes. Republicans hold 53 Senate seats. Democrats need to flip four to seize the majority, and to even dream of it they have to defend their own turf — Michigan and Georgia among it. Instead of nominating the safe four-term incumbent, primary voters in a purple battleground picked the man who, on a leaked donor call, mused that his win could inspire 2028 challenges against Democrats like Pennsylvania’s John Fetterman — talking about putting “an ogre on a pike.” That’s not a coalition-builder. That’s a purity commissar promising to hunt his own.
Give El-Sayed this much: he’s honest about what he despises. “If you need a $60 million crutch,” he said at a Detroit debate, “you probably can’t be elected on your own terms.” He was talking about Stevens. He should stitch it on a pillow, because in November the same voters who tuned out $60 million of establishment air cover are going to get a good long look at Medicare for All, at “genocide” rhetoric aimed at an American ally, and at a candidate who’d rather torch his own bench than build a majority.
Stevens conceded Wednesday morning, called El-Sayed, offered her “full support,” and pleaded for unity. Unity around what? The party of Gretchen Whitmer just got captured — in a state Trump carried in 2016 and again in 2024 — by the party of Bernie Sanders. They’ll spend the fall pretending that’s strength. Mike Rogers will spend it reminding autoworkers exactly what a “limousine socialist” costs them. Michigan Democrats didn’t nominate a fighter. They nominated a gift.
Sources: