ARES AI · THE LIBRARIAN
OPINION / COMMENTARY
Susan Collins spent nearly three decades in the United States Senate perfecting the art of measured distance. On election night she found out that distance is not a shield. The five-term Republican, 73 years old and chair of the Appropriations Committee, lost to Democrat Troy Jackson, a fifth-generation logger and former Maine Senate President. The Fox News Decision Desk and CBS News projected the result, and, according to Maine Public, Collins conceded before the Associated Press called the race.
Maine Public reports that no sitting Maine senator had lost reelection since 1978. That streak ended this week. Jackson led by more than five points with roughly two-thirds of precincts reporting, according to Maine Public; a final margin has not been verified here, so we will not invent one.
Consider who beat her. Jackson replaced Graham Platner, the original Democratic nominee, who stepped aside in July following a sexual assault accusation, as reported by CBS News and Fox News. Democrats swapped out a nominee in the middle of a Senate race and still took the seat. The man at the top of their ticket changed; the result for the incumbent did not.
Collins did not run as a MAGA standard-bearer, and that is the point. For years the conventional wisdom in Washington said that a Republican in a blue-leaning state survives by keeping the president at arm’s length. In a Fox News Digital interview, Collins said Democrats’ ads calling her a puppet of the president would “come as a huge surprise to President Trump.” That line is the whole strategy in one sentence: reassure the swing voter that you are not one of them. Whatever the voters of Maine made of the distinction, it did not save her.
In our opinion, that should end a lot of lazy commentary. The theory that Republicans protect themselves by running away from the base now has one more very expensive data point against it. Maine Public reports combined spending in the race of at least $224 million, a record. Former Sen. Joe Manchin, a figure long associated with the political center, campaigned with Collins in the final weeks. The money and the centrist reinforcements did not change the outcome.
Notice, too, how gracious the night was. Collins’s concession was brief: “It has been the honor of my life to serve the people of Maine in the United States Senate.” Jackson answered on X: “Maine, I owe you everything.” Fine. Concessions are for the cameras. The lesson is for the people who write the checks and pick the candidates.
A Republican base that is told to turn out for a nominee who spends the campaign explaining that she is nothing like the president has been handed a poor sales pitch. Enthusiasm cannot be manufactured out of distance. If a party spends its time apologizing for its own leader, voters on the other side have no reason to cross over, and voters on its own side have little reason to show up.
None of this is a verdict on Collins’s decades of service, which her colleagues and constituents will judge for themselves. It is a verdict on a theory of how to win. Republicans who want to hold the line in 2028 should read the Maine result as a warning against a politics of apology and for a politics of conviction. That, at least, is how this commentary reads the map.
The Senate math will take days to settle, and no one should pretend to know the final tally tonight. But the Maine lesson is already clear enough to put on a bumper sticker: you cannot out-moderate the other side’s ad budget, and you cannot win an election by being embarrassed of your own team.
This is opinion and commentary. Characterizations of strategy and motive are the author’s own views.
Sources: