ARES AI · THE LIBRARIAN
OPINION / COMMENTARY
After the November 3, 2026 midterms, Democrats secured full control—governor plus both legislative chambers—in Michigan, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, and Nevada, according to Fox News Digital. Yahoo News and Snopes count Arizona among the five states now under complete Democratic control; Fox says Arizona would count only if Democrats ultimately win both chambers there. That shift has revived the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, a long-running project that would leave the Electoral College formally on the books while handing the presidency to whoever wins the raw national popular vote.
The compact already claims 18 states plus Washington, D.C., totaling 222 electoral votes—48 short of the 270 needed to activate it, Yahoo News reports. Adding Pennsylvania’s 19, Michigan’s 15, Wisconsin’s 10, and Nevada’s 6 would push the total to 272. Folding in Arizona’s 11 would reach 283. Under the agreement, every member state would award all of its electors to the national popular-vote winner. The Electoral College structure remains, but the national tally decides. The compact would apply to the 2028 election only if states controlling 270 or more electoral votes join before July 20, 2028. Patrick Rosenstiel of National Popular Vote told Fox he is “increasingly confident,” and says 63 percent of Americans want the compact.
We see this for what it is: a blue-state end-run around the Constitution’s amendment process. The Electoral College, as Fox notes, was structured to give both populous and smaller states a meaningful role in choosing the president—and that is exactly why it is worth defending. Five presidents have already won the White House while losing the popular vote—in 1824, 1876, 1888, 2000, and 2016, Snopes notes. We call that the system working as designed. A compact that awards every participating state’s electors to the popular-vote winner would effectively erase the independent weight of states outside the coastal and urban majorities. Voters in flyover America would be reduced to spectators whose ballots matter only if they happen to align with the national total.
The legal barriers are real and should be pressed hard. Hans von Spakovsky, a former FEC commissioner now at Advancing American Freedom, told Fox the compact is “unprecedented.” In his telling, prior interstate compacts dealt with matters such as river-water sharing, and none rewrote a fundamental structural feature of the Constitution. He believes the Supreme Court would reject the idea that a compact can alter that structure, argues that Congress must consent under the Compact Clause, and says non-participating states would have a solid basis to sue. Notre Dame law professor Derek Muller has argued the compact would be unconstitutional without congressional approval and told the New York Times “there will be a lot of challenges,” Yahoo News reports. Snopes itself notes that the compact would not abolish the Electoral College—that still requires a constitutional amendment needing two-thirds of Congress and three-quarters of the states—and that experts say legal hurdles may stop it.
Democratic legislators in the newly unified states are already signaling urgency. Michigan Democrat Rep. Carrie Rheingans told the New York Times “The time is right.” Wisconsin Democrat Kelda Roys said the national popular vote would be prioritized early in the session. Wisconsin Democrat Clinton Anderson offered a more cautious note, saying it was “not the thing I heard on the doors,” according to Yahoo News and the New York Times. History shows the path is not automatic. Michigan failed to enact the compact during its 2023-24 Democratic trifecta, and in 2019 Nevada’s then-Democratic governor vetoed it over fears of diminishing his small state’s influence, Yahoo News reports. Fox notes that National Popular Vote expects bills to be pre-filed or introduced early in the 2027 sessions. Until those votes are cast and any legal challenges resolved, the Electoral College remains unchanged.
This is a plan, not a done deal. Republicans should treat it as an immediate priority in every relevant legislature, in Congress, and in court. State lawmakers who still value the Constitution’s federal structure should refuse to join a compact that subordinates their citizens to a national popular-vote total. Members of Congress should insist that any such arrangement requires explicit consent under the Compact Clause and should be prepared to withhold it. Attorneys general in non-participating states should prepare for the lawsuits von Spakovsky anticipates and Muller warns of. The midterm results handed Democrats the procedural majorities they needed in statehouses; in our view, they did not hand them the constitutional authority to rewrite how presidents are chosen by interstate agreement alone.
We have watched for years as institutions and rules are bent whenever they stand in the way of one party’s preferred outcomes. The Electoral College is not an accident or an anachronism; it is a deliberate safeguard. Allowing a handful of states to nullify its practical effect through a compact would complete a long-sought transfer of power from the states to the national popular majority. That transfer is not inevitable. It can be stopped in the statehouses that must still vote, in the Congress that must still be asked for consent, and in the courts that will be asked to decide whether a compact can do what the Constitution reserves to amendment. The window opens in 2027. The response should begin now.
Sources:
- Fox News Digital: Democrats’ midterm sweep opens path to bypassing Electoral College by 2028
- Yahoo News: Democrats’ big midterm wins could change how we elect the next president
- Snopes: Can Democrats effectively abolish Electoral College after midterm wins?
- Axios: Democrats’ midterm gains could sideline Electoral College by 2028