OPINION / COMMENTARY
Justice Samuel Alito just told a room full of conservatives that Congress holds the power to “turn off the lights” at the Supreme Court — and he said it days after Democrats won control of both chambers.
On Thursday night, November 12, 2026, Alito sat down with Mollie Hemingway at the Federalist Society’s Antonin Scalia Memorial Dinner during the National Lawyers Convention in Washington, D.C. More than 2,500 conservative elected officials, lawyers, judges and advocates filled the room, according to NBC News. Alito did not name the midterms. He didn’t have to. Democrats had just won the House and the Senate the week before. The timing was the message.
Alito reminded the audience that the judiciary is the “least dangerous” branch and is “vulnerable to the executive and to Congress because they are more powerful.” Then he put it in plain language: “Congress can turn off the lights of the Supreme Court and stop everything from happening if they will not fund their activities. And there are many, many, many other things that they can do, or at least try to do. So it is important to preserve the independence of the judiciary.”
That is not theory. Article III, Section 1 of the Constitution protects judicial salaries — “a Compensation, which shall not be diminished during their Continuance in Office” — but it does not protect the Court’s operating budget. The paychecks are insulated. The lights, the clerks, the security, the building itself are not. A hostile Congress could starve the institution without ever touching a salary line. Alito, nominated by President George W. Bush and on the Court since early 2006, knows exactly where the soft spot is.
He compared the Court not to a nuclear weapon or a 500-pound bomb, but to a hand grenade: “The hand grenade is the least dangerous, but that is not to say that is not dangerous.” The metaphor is deliberate. The Court can do damage, but it cannot wage total war. It depends on the other branches for its continued operation. When those branches are about to be run by the Court’s loudest critics, the danger is no longer abstract.
Alito then turned to the lower courts, where the real damage has been done for years. “The litigators, understandably, choose the districts where they think they are most likely to get the result they want. Their expectations are very often met.” He said that in some instances judges have issued “very sweeping and unjustified orders” stopping what the president wants while appeals drag on for years. The result is predictable: “So, if at the end of that period it turns out that the district judge was wrong, the president, whoever it is, will have been prevented for most of a four-year term from implementing” the initiative.
That is not judicial review. That is veto by injunction. Alito described the judges themselves with precision: “They are dedicated and they are skillful, but they’re not perfect, and they make mistakes. And in some instances, I think they have gone far astray.” Those orders, he said, helped drive the rise of the Supreme Court’s emergency docket over the past 10 or 15 years. Presidents frustrated with Congress look for ways to act on their own; opponents race to court to block them. The emergency docket became the only practical answer.
NBC News reported that the Trump administration has had a very high success rate on that emergency — or “shadow” — docket. Interim rulings have allowed it to move forward with immigration enforcement, restructuring of the federal government, and even construction of a White House ballroom while the underlying cases continue. Those are not final victories. They are temporary permissions to govern while the lower courts sort themselves out. Without them, entire policy agendas die in a handful of hand-picked district courts.
With Democrats about to take both chambers, the warning Alito delivered is no longer academic. Nothing in the reporting on his remarks points to a specific bill to defund the Court. But the institutional power he described is about to pass to a party that, in this column’s view, has spent the last decade treating the Court as an obstacle rather than a coordinate branch. The incentives that produced forum-shopping and sweeping district-court orders have not gone anywhere. A Congress that controls the purse can amplify that pressure without ever drafting a formal “defund” measure. It can simply squeeze the activities it dislikes and dare the Court to operate in the dark.
Alito’s point is bigger than any one election. Judicial independence survives only as long as the other branches choose not to strangle it. When the purse is about to change hands to the side whose allies have leaned hardest on lower-court injunctions to stop this President, the risk calculation changes. The hand grenade is still the least dangerous weapon in the arsenal. It is not harmless. And Congress, Alito just reminded everyone, holds the pin.
Sources: